Top U.S. Intelligence Analyst Accuses White House of Fraud About Syrian Sarin Gas Attack

Eric Zuesse

On April 18th, Washingtonsblog received from MIT’s Dr. Theodore Postol a detailed scientific analysis of the source-material for the White House Report on the gas-attack that occurred in Syria on April 4th. In it, he essentially accuses the Trump White House of having perpetrated a fraud so as to ‘justify’ its bombing of the Syrian Army’s air base. His article (along with a brief introduction about Dr. Postol’s background in the subject) can be found here:

My summary of it by excerpts from it, highlights certain passages with boldface type, in order to expedite a reader’s understanding Dr. Postol’s analysis.

The cover-letter of his full analysis states:

This analysis contains a detailed description of the times and locations of critical events in the alleged nerve agent attack of April 4, 2017 in Khan Shaykhun, Syria – assuming that the White House Intelligence Report (WHR) issued on April 11, 2017 correctly identified the alleged sarin release site.

Analysis using weather data from the time of the attack shows that a small hamlet about 300 m to the east southeast of the crater is the only location that could be affected by the alleged nerve agent release.  Video data of suffocating and dead victims lying on the ground shows a different location from the predicted sarin dispersal site if it had been correctly identified by the White House.

The conclusion is that the nerve agent attack described in the White House Intelligence Report did not occur as claimed.  There may well have been mass casualties from some kind of poisoning event, but that event was not the one described by the WHR.

The findings of this expanded analysis can serve two important purposes:

1 It shows exactly what needs to be determined in an international investigation of this alleged atrocity.

In particular, if an international investigation can determine where casualties from the nerve agent attack lived, it will confirm that the findings reported by the White House Report are incompatible with its own cited data.

2 It also establishes that the White House Report did not utilize simple and widely agreed upon intelligence analysis procedures to determine its conclusions.

This raises troubling questions about how the US political and military leadership determined that the Syrian government was responsible for the alleged attack.  It is particularly of concern that the White House Report presented itself as a report with “high confidence” findings and that numerous high-level officials in the US government have confirmed their belief that the report was correct and executed to a standard of high confidence.

This is Dr. Postal’s fourth report on the matter. Each of the prior three reports is also linked-to in the latest article.

Highlights of this, the fourth Postol analysis of the White-House-alleged Syrian gas attack, include:

“The conclusion of this summary of data is obvious – the nerve agent attack described in the W[hite] H[ouse] R[eport] did not occur as claimed. There may well have been mass casualties from some kind of poisoning event, but that event was not the one described by the W[hite] H[ouse] R[eport].”

“At the time of the sarin release, the temperature of the air was about 60°F and the sun was at an angle of only 8° relative to local horizontal. This means that liquid sarin left on the ground from the dispersal event would remain mostly unevaporated. By 11 AM, the temperature of the air had risen to 75° and the angle of the sun relative to horizontal was at 66°. Thus, one would expect that the combination of the rise in air temperature and the sun on the crater would lead to significant evaporation of liquid sarin left behind from the initial dispersal event. The air temperature and sun angle are such that the area around the crater should have been quite dangerous for anybody without protection to operate.

“Media is hiding this from us! Share this with the world.” [Photo  here is shown, of an alleged rescue-worker at the alleged crater of the alleged sarin-bomb. Caption is:] “Man without protective equipment standing next to the crater at 10:50 AM on April 4 —roughly 4 hours after the sarin release alleged by White House Report”

“Thus, the Hamlet area 300 m downwind of the crater is the only area where mass casualties could occur if there had been a sarin release at the crater as alleged bythe WHR!”

“Unprotected civilians with clothing that have logos of the Idlib Health Directorate are tampering with the contents of the crater that the WHR alleges was the source of the sarin release. All of the indicators point to a ruptured tube that could have contained no more than 8 to 10 liters of sarin. This is the only container shown in any videos from this scene.”

“What is absolutely clear from the videos is that the location of the sarin dispersal site alleged by WHR and the mass casualty site that would have had to be generated if the sarin dispersal actually occurred [in the way that the White House alleges], are not in any way related to the scenes of victims shown in the other videos. The conclusion is obvious: the alleged attack described in WHR never occurred.”

“Final Comments

This abbreviated summary of the facts has been constructed entirely from basic physics, video evidence, and absolutely solid analytical methods. It demonstrates without doubt that the sarin dispersal site alleged as the source of the April 4, 2017 sarin attack in Khan Sheikhoun was not a nerve agent attack site.

It also shows beyond a shadow of a doubt that the only mass casualty site that could have resulted from this mass attack [as alleged by the White House] is not in any way related to the sites that are shown in video following a poisoning event of some kind at Khan Sheikhoun.

This means that the allegedly “high confidence” White House intelligence assessment issued on April 11 that led to the conclusion that the Syrian government was responsible for the attack is not correct. For such a report to be so egregiously in error, it could not possibly have followed the most simple and proven intelligence methodologies to determine the veracity of its findings.

Since the United States justified attacking a Syrian airfield on April 7, four days before the flawed National Security Council intelligence report was released to the Congress and the public, the conclusion that follows is that the United States took military actions without the intelligence to support its decision.

Furthermore, it is clear that the WHR was not an intelligence report.”


Investigative historian Eric Zuesse is the author, most recently, of  They’re Not Even Close: The Democratic vs. Republican Economic Records, 1910-2010, and of  CHRIST’S VENTRILOQUISTS: The Event that Created Christianity.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.
  • Taras77

    Much appreciate analysis by someone who clearly knows what he is doing. Contrast that with the political hacks in defense, state, and white house and one can only be ashamed to be an American, at least ashamed of his govt. How many were killed as a result of this outrageous sham-maybe Ivanka would agree to sit down with the widows and children and explain why their husbands/fathers were killed.

    This episode again clearly illustrates that no one, not one person, can believe what the govt and its shills in the press can believe anything that is presented-the neo cons are in control and facts and truth do not matter.

  • slorter

    The intention is to keep the war machine rolling along!

  • Eric Zuesse

    The key thing here is that this news-report was submitted to all U.S. national-news media; google the headline to find out how many of them published it. Here is the top American military intelligence analyst, denying and disproving what all of those media are reporting, but how many of those media are even reporting his study? They can’t deny anything that he is saying, but will they report what he is saying? And, if not, then what does that indicate regarding whether the U.S. is a democracy, or instead a dictatorship?

    • Jonn Mero

      Not a particular US phenomenon, Eric. It is much the same with newspapers here in Norway, and most of Europe: they just fall in line with the official US reports, and present that blindly as truthful reporting. And the papers here try to sell their sad rags, but are steadily depending more on empty ‘news’, like elsewhere where what the Kardashian pea-brains are doing is presented as ‘news’. In a time when proper knowledge is readily available, it also seems like the public prefer their low-brow nonsense.

      • Eric Zuesse

        Thanks, Jonn, I know that what you are saying is true, but I focus most on shaming U.S. ‘news’media because their change would force change among the media of America’s allied dictatorships, which I see as basically vassal-states within the American empire. I appreciate your sharing your own experience on that, as a Norwegian, and I think that it’s like that throughout the empire. But I just wanted to explain to you and other readers why I say “U.S.” and mean far more than just that.

  • seesee2468

    It is obvious that it was Al Qaeda (Al Nusra), not Syria, that made a false-flag chemical weapons attack of some sort. No CW attack allegation against the Syrian government has ever been proven, and CW attacks by Al Qaeda and ISIS are common, as even the NYT admitted last year. For example, just yesterday ISIS terrorists made three chemical attacks in Mosul:
    What we need to know more about is: 1) did Trump know the WH report was completely fake or are his advisors deceiving him? and 2) did the US leak the time of the scheduled Syrian air attack to Al Qaeda in Khan Sheikhoun or have an even more secret role in the false flag attack?

    • Gloriajhill

      Managing director of Google!, is explaining to users to start off “Work at home” method, that People have been doing for about one year now. These days alone, I generated close to $36,000 until now with no more than my home computer as well as some spare time, despite that i have a fulltime 9 to 5 job. Even everyone not used to this, can make $89/per h easily and the earnings can go even higher over time… This is how i started
      ➽➽➽➽ http://GoogleFinancialCashJobs580OfficeTech/GetPaid$97/Hour ★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫:::!wr580u:…..

    • Shirleymjackson

      Managing director of Google!, is explaining to users to start off “Work at home” method, that People have been doing for about one year now. These days alone, I generated close to $36,000 until now with no more than my home computer as well as some spare time, despite that i have a fulltime 9 to 5 job. Even everyone not used to this, can make $89/per h easily and the earnings can go even higher over time… This is how i started
      ➽➽➽➽ http://GoogleFinancialCashJobs367SmartMedia/GetPaid$97/Hour ★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫★✫★★✫:::!wr367u:……..

  • Richard Arlen


  • Jonn Mero

    Just hope that all decent US citizens get behind Tulsi Gabbard (and Bernie Sanders) as the only really sane and intelligent voices among US politicians. Remarkable how many have learned absolutely nothing after the string of failures in US foreign policies. Sadly, European and Australian politicians are just minions for the lunatics in Washington. And the loonies in Washington are in the pocket of the military-industrial complex, so wars are the easiest way to channel taxpayers’ money to the 1%ers. Crap, isn’t it?

    • Eric Zuesse

      Tulsi Gabbard, especially, she has been by far the most courageous on international affairs, far more than Sanders has been.

  • Marko

    You can pretty much bet that the environmental samples from the impact crater will test positive for sarin consistent with Assad’s stockpile. That will be the cherry on top for another Oscar-deserving production.

    Those dead from sarin were not “exposed” , they were murdered. Aside from the 20 or so from a single family , it appears that the bulk of the dead were not residents :

    ” No one knows for sure the exact death toll, because some of the dead were refugees from the neighbouring province of Hama who sought shelter here, and their relatives took them home for burial.” ( For “refugees” , read “captives”. )

    The now-rockstar “man with twins” who lost 19 , 20 , 22 , or 25 family members , depending on who was counting , is named Abdul Hamid al-Yousef , and is shown here ( in checked shirt ) with Erdogan at the hospital in Turkey:

    To me , he appears awfully similar to the guy against the wall at the back of the room in this earlier picture depicting one of the regular McCain/terrorists strategy sessions :

    If that is Mr. Man-with-Twins with McCain , I think he’s going to be one very wealthy man when this is all over with.

  • Phorie