Continuing EU Membership for Indy Scotland is Possible – Special EU Status for Scotland in the UK is Impossible

Alyn Smith was excellent in the European Parliament yesterday. He was doing exactly what the SNP need to be doing – building sympathy in the European institutions for continuing Scottish membership of the EU.

The European Union is an institution which is based on treaties which have legal force. There is nothing whatsoever in any of those treaties, and nothing in any existing arrangement with any state, that makes it possible for part of a state, even a federal state, to be inside the EU, when the state itself is outside.

There is absolutely no way that Scotland can be inside both the UK and EU, if the UK is outside the EU. This question has been visited before by the EU in detail, in relation to Cyprus in particular . I understand that Nicola Sturgeon may feel a need to show that she explored all possibilities. But there is a serious danger of confusing the issue by asking for impossible things that will just exasperate people and lose sympathy.

It is very possible indeed to work out modalities for independent Scotland to join as an EU member at precisely the same moment the UK leaves. Indeed, the creation of a new doctrine of right to retain EU citizenship that makes it possible for recognised EU “regions”, of which Scotland is one, to achieve statehood and continue membership, only if the member state is leaving the EU, could alleviate potential Spanish opposition.

Such a solution can politically be stitched together. The reaction to Alyn Smith’s speech demonstrates that. Absolutely crucially – and I cannot emphasise the importance of this enough – no treaty changes would be required for Scotland as a newly independent state to continue membership. But any kind of special status for Scotland when it is not a state, would require treaty changes which we are just not going to get.

I spent four years of mu life as First Secretary (Political and Economic) in the British Embassy in Warsaw working specifically on Poland’s EU accession. I not only know this stuff backwards, I know a lot of key contacts. Alyn Smith shows that the SNP MEPs know what they are doing and are highly capable. I am consumed by desire to find a way to help my country at this crucial time. Having thought I had achieved some kind of acceptance that in the UK whistleblowers are forever excluded from public life, I today find it hurting more than ever.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.
  • ICFubar

    An independent Scotland within the EU is the biggest political nonsense I’ve heard in a long long time. What will Scotland use for money in their independence? The Pound? I don’t think so. The Euro? Then forget any independence within that Union. Perhaps they could use golf balls of different brands for the smaller denominations and curling stones for the larger, money making the world go round. Scotland in the EU will become a new version of the Baltics within the EU. but fill your boots if you think it will work out. The rest of the world awaits the emigration of your brightest and best.

  • ahuxley

    The debate of this hypothetical issue is a waste of time.
    Does anyone think that the European Parasitic Aristocracy will actually allow a populist insurrection to dilute their power and wealth scam?
    The sitting EU aristocracy, no doubt, have at their disposal myriad machinations to thwart this attempt by Brits to throw off the yoke the vermin in Brussels. The UK will NOT be allowed to leave the EU.