The Palestinian Right and the American Left

Chris Hedges says that Palestinians have the right to self-defense in the form of rockets, without including any consideration of whether the rockets make the Palestinians more or less defended.  There is, after all, a reasonable argument that the rockets are counter-productive and endangering, rather than protecting, Palestine.

Legally, if we ignore the Kellogg-Briand Pact and stick to the U.N. Charter, much less its frequent abuse by the powerful nations of the world, there is no doubt that Hedges is correct.  If demolishing Iraqi or Afghan or Libyan or Pakistani or Yemeni homes is “defense” of the United States, then surely the people of Gaza, under actual attack, have the legal right to shoot rockets at Israel.  That’s just basic Western consensus with the hypocrisy removed.

“[M]any Palestinians, especially young men trapped in overcrowded hovels where they have no work and little dignity,” writes Hedges, “will risk immediate death to defy the slow, humiliating death of occupation. I cannot blame them.”

Here are the false choices framed: either we blame the victims of Israel’s vicious and massive assault on a trapped population, blame them for reacting as virtually anyone else in the so-called developed world would, or we advocate for the right to fight defensive wars — regardless of whether it helps or hurts the situation.  Those are not the only options.

I’m not sure I can prove that the rockets hurt the situation, but to render the question inadmissible seems fatally flawed.  The justification that the U.S. Congress and White House use for arming Israel and seeking to shelter Israel from legal consequences is always and exclusively the rockets.  The justification that Israeli spokespeople use on television is likewise almost entirely the rockets.  In a world without the rockets, would other excuses prove successful? It’s hard to say for sure.  But the rockets provide the public packaging for Israeli war-making, accomplish virtually nothing in military terms, and almost certainly do more to frighten and enrage the people of Israel than to bring Israelis around to sympathizing with the plight of their government’s victims.

I’ve just spoken by phone with a smart writer in Gaza named Sarah Ali for an upcoming edition of Talk Nation Radio.  She explained to me quite eloquently how Israeli attacks on Gaza were generating support for Hamas and violence against Israel.  She described the emotional need to fight back.  So, I asked her if rocket attacks on Israel weren’t likewise counterproductive. No, she said, she imagined that Israelis saw the rockets and began to understand the point of view of Palestinians.  In the absence of any evidence of that phenomenon, I can only say that I’ll believe it when I see it.  In every case I’m aware of in which one nation has militarily attacked another, it has done far more to enrage than to stimulate sympathy in the people coming under attack.

Of course, I have no right to tell the people of Gaza what to do or not do from the comfort of my home in the heart of the imperial monster that is funding their apocalypse.  Of course I cannot know the situation as they know it.  But it’s not clear to me that every Gazan has as deep a familiarity with Israelis or every Israeli with Gazans as one might imagine from their geographic vicinity.  The division between these two societies is extreme.  How else could Israelis imagine children as their enemies?  And how else could those children’s parents imagine that firing rockets would win over hearts and minds?

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail
This entry was posted in General. Bookmark the permalink.
  • Carl_Herman

    Nice; great points, David. Thank you.

  • jadan

    Its not likely that Hamas believes that rockets will achieve any military advantage. It’s more likely that they know exactly the consequences of provoking the Israelis. And this is what they want, this brutal military assault against harmless people that Israeli racists hate and enjoy smiting in a Biblical fashion every few years. This keeps the rage alive in the Palestinians. The numbers of martyrs grows exponentially. They do not fear death. What can the Israeli fascists do but demonstrate to the world that they are a nation of racist murderers? They’re exasperated. And they’re scared that they, too, may soon have to die like the Palestinians they are slaughtering with such impunity. If they could simply eradicate these inconvenient people off the planet as does happen in their Biblical fantasies they would. But they cannot. Hamas will stay with the rockets to provoke them and cause some discomfort, property damage and maybe even kill a few of them. They are not afraid of death & suffering. They do it much better than the Israelis who have forgotten how to suffer and die. All they know is techno death inflicted on a helpless population, kind of like Nazis vis a vis the Warsaw Ghetto. It is a repulsive spectacle. The Israelis are morally bankrupt. That is what the rockets show the world. It is the one effective strategy the Palestinians have.

  • rodneystich

    My view, have worked as an airline captain in the Middle East, is stated at http://www.defraudingamerica.com/israel_index, and at http://www.defraudingamerica.com/palestine_reports.