How Much Is NSA Spying Costing In Lost Productivity?

Spy Agencies Are Spying On All Of Us, Taking Screenshots of Our Webchats, Creating Vulnerabilities On Our Computers and the Internet, and Intentionally Disrupting Some of Our Functionalities …

NSA spying is costing the U.S. tech industry tens of billions of dollars. And see this and this.

It also undermines trust in U.S. companies, fellow Americans and our government. Given that trust is the foundation for a prosperous economy, this is really bad for our economy.

But there might be another big cost to mass surveillance: loss of worker productivity.

Specifically, top computer and internet experts say that NSA spying breaks the functionality of our computers and of the Internet. It reduces functionality and reduces security by – for example – creating backdoors that malicious hackers can get through.

Remember, American and British spy agencies have intentionally weakened security for many decades. And it’s getting worse and worse. For example, they plan to use automated programs to infect millions of computers.

How much time and productivity have we lost in battling viruses let in because of the spies tinkering? How much have we lost because “their” computer programs conflict with “our” programs?

Indeed, Microsoft’s general counsel labels government snooping an “advanced persistent threat,” a term generally used to describe teams of hackers that coordinate cyberattacks for foreign governments.  It is well-known  among IT and security professionals  that hacking decreases employee productivity.    While they’re usually referring to hacking by private parties, the same is likely true for hacking by government agencies, as well.

And the spy agencies are already collecting millions of webcam images from our computers. THAT’S got to tie up our system resources … so we can’t get our work done as fast.

Moreover, the Snowden documents show that the American and British spy agencies launched attacks to disrupt the computer networks of “hacktivists” and others they don’t like, and tracked supporters of groups such as Wikileaks.

Given that the spy agencies are spying on everyone, capturing millions of screenshots, intercepting laptop shipments, creating fake versions of popular websites to inject malware on people’s computers, launching offensive cyber-warfare operations against folks they don’t like, and that they may view journalism, government criticism or even thinking for one’s self as terrorism – and tend to re-label “dissidents” as “terrorists” – it’s not unreasonable to assume that all of us are being adversely effected to one degree or another by spy agency operations.

How much loss of productivity has this caused?

I’ll hazard a guess: billions of dollars of lost productivity as a nation.

Afterword: Bill Binney – the high-level NSA executive who created the agency’s mass surveillance program for digital information, a 32-year NSA veteran widely regarded as a “legend” within the agency, the senior technical director within the agency, who managed thousands of NSA employees – tells Washington’s Blog:

There are several sides to spying costs. First, is the lack of thinking by the government and industry as to the consequences of their activities being exposed. That turns out to be cost in commercial sales and futures/trust.

The other costs involve weakening systems (operating systems/firewalls/encryption).  When they do that, this weakens the systems for all to find. Hackers around the world as well as governments too.

These costs are hard to count. For example, we hear of hackers getting customer data over and over again. Is that because of what our government has done?

Or, how about all the attacks on systems in government? Are these because of weakened systems?

Bottom line, if we (including our government) don’t help solve weaknesses in these systems, then we all lose.

This entry was posted in Business / Economics, Politics / World News, Science / Technology. Bookmark the permalink.
  • jo6pac
  • wunsacon

    >> I’ll hazard a guess: billions of dollars of lost productivity as a nation.

    You’re probably low-balling that figure, to avoid ridicule.

    I suspect some of the smartest people in the country end up working as white hats and black hats. In the meantime, they’re not curing cancer!

  • Tatiana Covington

    Death by a thousand cuts?

  • james

    Worst is that we just lost our software industry in one fell swoop.

    Ask Microsoft how many overseas companies are actively buying their products right now and not asking about NSA spying – none…

    Ask Oracle the same thing…

    Ask Apple, Adobe, IBM… All dead internationally because of NSA spying – and if they aren’t dead yet, it’s only because other countries haven’t developed their own yet.

    Ask the cell phone switch providers if they are selling anything to others.

    Think our economy is tanking today? Wait five years or so.

    NSA is a parasite sucking the blood right out of its host and suffocating it bit by bit.


  • Mick Price

    Let’s not forget the loss of productivity in the financial markets from government agents insider trading on the information. You speculators make money by examining information and buying or selling what is likely to go up or down (respectively). By doing this they get prices to the right place faster, making the whole system work better.

    However they can only do that if someone doesn’t steal the information and buy/sell the thing first. Why pay to research when someone can simply make the same bets you are by just tapping your phone and internet?

    And before you say I’m paranoid, guess who does a LOT better than the market every year? SEC employees.