Virtually ALL of the Big Banks’ Profits Come from Taxpayer Bailouts and Subsidies

The Big Banks “Would Just About Break Even In the Absence of Corporate Welfare”

The government has propped up the big banks for years through massive, never-ending bailouts and subsidies.

Bloomberg noted last year that 77% of JP Morgan’s net income comes from government subsidies.

Bloomberg reported yesterday:

What if we told you that, by our calculations, the largest U.S. banks aren’t really profitable at all? What if the billions of dollars they allegedly earn for their shareholders were almost entirely a gift from U.S. taxpayers?


Lately, economists have tried to pin down exactly how much the subsidy lowers big banks’ borrowing costs. In one relatively thorough effort, two researchers — Kenichi Ueda of the International Monetary Fund and Beatrice Weder di Mauro of the University of Mainz — put the number at about 0.8 percentage point. The discount applies to all their liabilities, including bonds and customer deposits.

Small as it might sound, 0.8 percentage point makes a big difference. Multiplied by the total liabilities of the 10 largest U.S. banks by assets, it amounts to a taxpayer subsidy of $83 billion a year. To put the figure in perspective, it’s tantamount to the government giving the banks about 3 cents of every tax dollar collected.

The top five banks — JPMorgan, Bank of America Corp., Citigroup Inc., Wells Fargo & Co. and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. – – account for $64 billion of the total subsidy, an amount roughly equal to their typical annual profits (see tables for data on individual banks). In other words, the banks occupying the commanding heights of the U.S. financial industry — with almost $9 trillion in assets, more than half the size of the U.S. economy — would just about break even in the absence of corporate welfare. In large part, the profits they report are essentially transfers from taxpayers to their shareholders.

The money hasn’t just gone to the banks shareholders … It has also gone to line the pockets of bank management:


All of the monetary and economic policy of the last 3 years has helped the wealthiest and penalized everyone else. See this, this and this.


Economist Steve Keen says:

“This is the biggest transfer of wealth in history”, as the giant banks have handed their toxic debts from fraudulent activities to the countries and their people.

Nobel economist Joseph Stiglitz said in 2009 that Geithner’s toxic asset plan “amounts to robbery of the American people”.

And economist Dean Baker said in 2009 that the true purpose of the bank rescue plans is “a massive redistribution of wealth to the bank shareholders and their top executives”.

We’ve noted for years that the big banks – including Citi, Wells, Bank of America and the rest – are actually insolvent.

Breaking up the big banks would stabilize the economy … and dramatically increase Main Street’s access to credit.

But the government has chosen the banks over the little guy … dooming both:

The big banks were all insolvent during the 1980s.

And they all became insolvent again in 2008. See this and this.

The bailouts were certainly rammed down our throats under false pretenses.

But here’s the more important point. Paulson and Bernanke falsely stated that the big banks receiving Tarp money were healthy, when they were not. They were insolvent.

Tim Geithner falsely stated that the banks passed some time of an objective stress test but they did not. They were insolvent.

Both the creditors and the debtors were mortally wounded by the 2008 financial crisis. The big banks wouldn’t have survived without trillions in handouts, guarantees, loans, idiot-proof profits courtesy of the government.

The little guy hasn’t been helped since 2008. He has been left to suffer with his life-threatening wounds. See this, this and this.

So the government chose sides. The creditors were wiped out, just like a lot of Main Street was wiped out. In one sense, the government chose who would live (the giant banks and other bailed out and favored companies) and who would die (the other 99%).

But in fact, the big banks were no longer creditors after the 2008 crash. Specifically, the big banks which held the mortgages and the loans were wiped out.

The government moved the arms and legs of the big banks to pretend they were still alive … and have been doing so ever since. But they were no longer going concerns after they went bust.

The government pumped blood back in these dead banks and turned them into zombies. They will never come back to life in a real sense … they are still zombies, 3 years later.

Many of the world’s leading economists and financial experts say that by choosing creditors over debtors, the government is dooming the economy. See this and this.

The big zombie banks can never come back to life, and – by trying to save them – the government is bleeding out the little guy.

By choosing the big banks over the little guy, the government is dooming both.

Remember, the Federal Reserve has paid banks high interest rates to stash money (their “excess reserves”) with the Fed for the express purpose of preventing loans to Main Street.

And the Fed plans to throw more money at the banks when the Federal Reserve starts to tighten.  As FT reports:

US Federal Reserve officials fear a backlash from paying billions of dollars to commercial banks when the time comes to raise interest rates.

The growth of the Fed’s balance sheet means it could pay $50bn-$75bn a year in interest on bank reserves at the same time as it makes losses and has to stop sending money to the Treasury.


In an interview with the Financial Times, James Bullard, president of the St Louis Fed, said: “If you think of the profitability of the biggest banks, if you’re going to talk about paying them something of the order of $50bn – well that’s more than the entire profits of the largest banks.”


At the moment it only pays 0.25 per cent interest on those reserves. But according to its exit strategy, published in June 2011, the Fed plans to raise interest rates before it sells assets. Interest of 2 per cent on $2.5tn of reserves would run to $50bn a year.


The eventual tightening could lead to substantial amounts being transferred to commercial banks from the Fed, given the amounts of cash they have parked there. Wells Fargo has $97.1bn sitting at the Fed, the largest amount of any bank, ahead of JPMorgan Chase at $88.6bn and Goldman Sachs at $58.7bn, according to an FT analysis of SNL data.

Foreign banks also have a striking amount of cash at the Fed, potentially aggravating the Fed’s PR problem. Analysts at Stone & McCarthy noted recently that there had been a steep increase in foreign banks placing reserves at the Fed and suggested that “US banks may have distaste for the opportunistic arbitrage”, between lower market rates and the interest on reserves, whereas overseas institutions “might not feel encumbered in the same fashion”.

Canada’s TD Bank, Germany’s Deutsche Bank and Switzerland’s UBS each have more than $12bn at the Fed.

And while this post focuses on bailouts and subsidies to big American banks,  a large percentage of the bailouts went to foreign banks (and see this). And so did a huge portion of the money from quantitative easing. More here and here.

This entry was posted in Business / Economics, Politics / World News. Bookmark the permalink.
  • nveric

    So, it’s in one door and out the next.

    Common thought of some people is that corporations control things, as in controlling government. While the appearance is there, the only ones who actually vote, that is vote with a V, are those in Congress. Bought or not, it’s still 535 people in CONGRESS who VOTE for these crappy laws and bills. The action is and has always been in Congress, unless their voting is being manipulated, but then they would notice, it stands to reason, because they can see the results.

    This is something the People never actually see, that is, if their vote actually is recorded correctly. Never has a citizen vote ever been known to be applied correctly, because we have a secret/private voting system. Our vote and name are never seen to confirm what we did – NEVER.

    P.S. – 80 years ago or so, the number was 535 people in Congress. 80 years without any increase in representation. There’s 3 times the population now, but not a single increase in those representing us, the People.

  • nveric

    With money and its supply not anchored to a tangible thing for conversion, but rather anchored to itself, as if it were possible to lift oneself up, the supply and records pertaining to money is not something which is founded in reality. This means the banks and “Bankers” don’t actually control something of value independent of itself.

    Money and/or currency has no intrinsic value. I know this is a no brainer, but people tend to consider money/currency as having special properties like gold and silver. All forms of money/currency are abstractions and are not independently real, thus their worth and control are illusions people give them.

    • Fullblad

      The same thing applies to precious metals, though they do have some industrial value as does paper. You can’t eat either. Money should represent the industriousness and good credit of the people…and be owned by the people.

  • gozounlimited

    Some Fun facts ……

    Emails Prove JPMorgan Committed Massive Mortgage Fraud …..

    JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon has tried his best to suggest that the financial crisis was someone else’s fault. But a batch of court documents released this week undermine this claim, indicating that the bank knew the mortgage investments it sold were seriously flawed. read more:

    Madoff Emails CNBC From Prison, Accuses JPM Of Fraud …. Madoff and big banks complicit in fraud….. read more:
    Slimin’ Jamie Dimon’s Scheming to Stick the FDIC with WaMu Losses – Yves Smith

    We’ve been told that in the next few weeks, JP Morgan is about to enter into a settlement with Deutsche Bank regarding…hold your breath….the liabilities it insists sit with the FDIC. I’m not making this up (the source is legally savvy). I’m not even sure how you paper up something which is so clearly nonsensical.
    read more:
    BANK FRAUD: The Rise Of Zombie Foreclosures …..

    In these “zombie foreclosures,” borrowers move out after their bank schedules a foreclosure auction only to learn months or yearslater that the auction never took place or the bank never transferred
    the deed. That means the borrower still technically owns the house and is on the hook for property taxes, fees and homeowners’ association dues. ….. read more:
    States Join Lawsuit Challenging BACK DOOR Bailouts …..BEN AND MARIO UP IN SMOKE

    These Stoners are blowing some smoke
    They’re hiding the fact that they’re broke
    The only contagion
    Is growth that they’re stagin’
    It’s time drugged-up sheeple awoke!

    The Limerick King ….. read more:
    Heinz Insider Trading Came From Goldman Sachs Account …..

    The SEC said that the traders had advance material nonpublic information about the impending deal when they used an omnibus account in Zurich to buy 2,533 out-of-the-money June call options, which had a strike price of $65 on Feb. 13. Shares closed that day at $60.48.

    The defendants, using the Goldman Sachs account, invested almost $90,000 in option positions the day before the deal was announced, the SEC said. As a result, their position increased to more than $1.8 million, a rise of almost 2,000 percent. ….read more:
    The Gods of the 21st Century ….. Who are the God’s of the 21st Century ….. see video:

  • Didn’t the banks pay back the bailout money with interest?

  • Plus, a few hundred billion related to drug money laundering.

  • izraulhidashi

    This is why I don’t understand the reasons in allowing scummy piece of shit Bankers, Politicians and Rich people to get away with murder, while they punish us just for breathing. None of the money our system operates on comes from those greedy bottom feeding low life’s. It all comes from us!

    They should be kissing our ass, and fucking them with sandpaper condoms instead. Abusing the hands that feed them will eventually end bad for these assholes. And the people who participate or allow this corruption to continue are only assuring that their great grandchildren will live in shittier times filled with more misery pain and abuse at the hands of future assholes 3x as corrupt as them. Good work!