No, Mentally Ill People Would NOT Necessarily Have Become Violent Without Anti-Depressants

Scientific Evidence Shows that New Anti-Depressants MAKE Disturbed People Violent

The number of school shootings, murders and murder-suicides, workplace violence, road rage, and random violence by soldiers by people taking anti-depressants is staggering.

It is a reasonable – but false - assumption that mentally disturbed people who commit violence would have done so whether or not they were on medication.

For example, the Journal of Psychiatry and Neuroscience published a study in 2001 showing that one modern anti-depressant is associated with violent acts.

David Healy and David Menkes from Cardiff University, and Andrew Herxheimer from the UK Cochrane Centre, published a study in 2006 showing that antidepressants can cause severe violence in a small number of individuals.

Numerous other mental health experts say that anti-depressants may be a substantial factor in school shootings and other gun-related violence. And see this, this, this, this.

If you have any doubt that anti-depressants cause violence in disturbed people, please watch this Congressional testimony by a top expert on anti-depressants:

And this short interview with a number of other mental health experts:

And these short videos:

So – whatever else we do to address school shootings – we must either stop pushing anti-depressants on kids or at least stop selling guns to people taking anti-depressants.

This entry was posted in General, Politics / World News, Science / Technology. Bookmark the permalink.
  • gozounlimited

    There is the “in your face gun violence” and then there is “the soft kill” both perpetrated on each of us by resonate evil. I don’t think anyone has missed the linear connection between our “corporate/government” (whom insists on being in control)” and the waste of human life…..

    Chemtrails Clearly Visible Above Newtown Connecticut School Shooting – Libor Connection

    http://aircrap.org/chemtrails-clearly-visible-above-newtown-connecticut-school-shooting-libor-connection/336115/

    • gozounlimited

      Another form of mental illness ….. mind control aided by chemtrails conducting ELF waves….. Chemtrails were visible overhead on Jan. 8, 2011 when Gabby Giffords was shot.

      ELF WAVES MIND CONTROL …. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Td6rGs_aLk0

      The Mind Control Agenda … http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T-08_iV5s08

    • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

      I certainly believe that doctor can possibly overprescribe SSRI and as a result we get situation like that.

  • TheWanderer

    I am a mentally ill professional. Without medication, I was unable to cope with life and rapidly heading for self-destruction. With medication, I hold down a position with a six-figure income. Do not take away my medication!!

    • Mike G

      Adults react differently to children on such medications. Lanza was 20 years old, so not a child, but not fully developed adult either. Also, everyone reacts differently to different medications. We still don’t know what he was on or how many different things.

      • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

        It is certain that Adam Lanza was prescribe too many antidepressants, in my view. Just my gut feeling

        • some pompous name

          you have no idea what he might or might not have been taking, nor do you have any evidence that can withstand scrutiny that proves beyond all reasonable doubt the he in fact even fired a shot!

          idiot…

          • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

            I am proposing antidepressants as a major factor, and it is just a suggestion. enuff said. you are a wortless dick of a idiot who just don’t read between the lines!!!!

          • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

            It is a common fact that some SSRI can incude suicidal thoughts, so it is certainly possible that the doctors overprescribed medications for Adam Lanza!

  • medicated and peaceful

    As someone who has taken anti-depressants for many years, and could not function without them, I can guarantee to you that they make me no more violent than I ever was (which is not at all). Everyone needs a scapegoat, but why would you pick a medicine that saves millions of lives every day? Educate yourself about depression and anxiety before you start talking out of your ass.

    • gozounlimited

      Placebo Effect?

    • Mike G

      Um, I think he plainly DID educate himself. Hence the evidence he presented. None of which is new or controversial. I took anti-depressants at one time, and believed the helped me, so I guess they did. However, there have now been a number of studies showing that Prozac (what I took) is no more effective than a placebo. Perhaps it’s time for you to do some research yourself perhaps instead of blindly trusting a profit driven industry?

    • paulbrye

      The antidepressants you take can very well improve your function, but being on antidepressants doesn’t make you any more qualified to opine on the subject than my dog. Everyone except you apparently knows that these drugs produce the dangerous effects under discussion in a fraction of the population who take them.

      • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

        I agree with you paul. i believe that there are doctors who constantly prescribing these SSRI without understanding the implication of these new medicines.

  • dgdgdg

    Author is an idiot, not a physician.

    • paulbrye

      The author is not a physician, so he reported the testimony of respected professionals and physicians, which makes your comment … idiotic.

  • http://twitter.com/vv111y vv111y

    So what I have just read is that Temple Grandin apparently claims that medication dosing needs to be much lower for autistic spectrum folks. If he was on fanapt, AFAIK not proven yet, then according to this site http://www.patientsville.com/medication/fanapt_side_effects.htm#reports the main patient reported side effects are:

    1Violent
    2Suicidal Thoughts
    3Violent And Suicidal Thoughts
    4SLURRED SPEECH AND DROOLING

  • steven andresen

    The shootings in Connecticut seem too pointless and so unnecessarily cruel that they demands some more explanation than just the guy had powerful weapons so he used them.
    The suggestion that he was on some medication for his autism that made him “snap” is a reasonable conjecture. One has to have evidence of what he might have been on before we could make any further suppositions. However, it does not appear that the authorities are going to let us know what medications he was on.
    The fact that these meds, the antideppresants, could make many people feel better and allow them to have better lives does not prove that these same meds could not have cause suicidal or homicidal thoughts in some small segment of the people who take them. There are many reasons why some people can’t tolerate certain drugs. So, the fact that “medicated and peaceful” or “the wanderer” are doing fine, does not prove that these drugs could not be implicated in these shooter’s behaviors.
    The claim that other than the gun issue, these shootings are a “mental health issue” seems to be a complete red herring. What kind of mental health issue? I think the shooter’s mental health situation seemed to have been unremarkable for all of his life. What would explain his sudden “snapping”. This sudden resort to senseless violence seems more the result of some change in his situation, like his not tolerating a mind altering pharmaceutical.
    I want to add that given the post-Constitutional mafia state we find ourselves, I have more sympathy with the 2nd Amendment crowd.

  • http://www.facebook.com/WoodWarbler Brian Aust

    You’re full of ignorant baloney. THis has no bearing on the Connecticut incident. Stop stereotyping US, that is, fully 1/3 of Americans. Antidepressants are designed to help and most of the time they do. The Newtown shooter wasn’t taking psychotropic meds; meanwhile, millions of us have had our lives saved by them. Your post and similar beliefs are stigmatizing and misinformed.

    • paulbrye

      Cite your proof the Newton shooter was not on psychotropic meds, please. Last I looked, the information had not been released, and the circumstantial evidence (not just the shootings) suggested he was on such meds.

    • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

      you brainless fuck. Read my comments above. I am pointing out that Adam Lanza’s doc may had overprescribed the SSRI and as a result he ended up the way he was!!!!!!

    • http://www.facebook.com/elyse.f.enger Elyse Frances Enger

      and have you heard of PRESCRIPTION DRUG ABUSE??? i also believe that some of the mass shooting has this as factors!

 

 

Twitter